• flipht
    link
    fedilink
    4411 months ago

    It’s also not a dead language by any stretch of the imagination. Even latin isn’t technically a dead language since it is still used.

    Imperialists calling something dead is often just wishful thinking.

    • Deceptichum
      link
      fedilink
      -2711 months ago

      A dead language is one that isn’t used by real people everyday, not a language some academics can still speak.

      That’s why Welsh and Irish are basically considered dead to many because the native speakers are so few that it could disappear very easily.

      Also who the fuck speaks Latin still? Does the papal city place in Italy even speak that during it’s day to do going ons?

      • @gmtom@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        3611 months ago

        What are you on about? Welsh is by no definition “basically considered a dead language” over 30% of the country can speak Welsh. And its on all official communication, like government websites, announcements, road signs etc.

      • @spirinolas@lemmy.world
        cake
        link
        fedilink
        2611 months ago

        That’s why Welsh and Irish are basically considered dead to many

        Uh…no. As far as I know, none of these languages are dead. Irish is dying but it’s not dead yet. Welsh is thriving and is pretty much the only Celtic language being passed down the next generation consistently and has a vigorous community with a respectable size.

        • @Borkingheck@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          611 months ago

          Unescos ratings are: Vulnerable, definitely endangered, severely endangered and critically endangered. Once a language loses all of its native speakers, it becomes an extinct language [but can be revived].

          Welsh and also Scots are vulnerable whilst Scottish Gaelic and Irish are definitely endangered.

        • Deceptichum
          link
          fedilink
          -811 months ago

          Oh sorry, excuse me for not remembering the paedophile palaces name.

          Honestly the Vatican isn’t worth remembering, along with the hate filled ideology it promotes.

      • @Borkingheck@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        1111 months ago

        A dead language is one which has no native speakers alive to speak it e.g Latin.

        Irish and Welsh aren’t dead. The only dead Celtic language im aware of (but it has been revived since) is Manx, with the last native speaker dying in the 1970s.

      • @charlytune@mander.xyz
        link
        fedilink
        811 months ago

        You know there are Welsh schools right? And that the Welsh government has two official languages, Welsh and English? And that all official documents have to be bilingual? I’ve heard people speaking Welsh to each other in Wales, and I know someone for whom Welsh is their first language.

        Does that sound dead?

      • Resol van Lemmy
        link
        fedilink
        711 months ago

        Technically, Latin is a dead language, but not an extinct language. It could (heavy emphasis on “could”) come back all of a sudden. That’s what happened to Hebrew.

        Extinct languages aren’t even spoken by anyone anymore. Not even a single soul. Gone beyond the point of repair. Disappeared for good, like dinosaurs and dodo birds and megalodon.