I use plasma, BTW

  • @AVincentInSpace
    link
    English
    16
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    It’s not systemd doing all the things completely unrelated to system initialization that it does that I have a problem with. It’s systemd doing them worse than the existing tools that do those things that the systemd equivalents replace and Lennart Poettering being completely unable to fathom why anyone would ever want to use any piece of software other than his. systemd talks big game about being modular, but makes breaking changes to how those modules communicate without warning anyone, so if you dare to be a “systemd hater” as he calls them and replace one of those modules with an equivalent he isn’t involved with, Heaven help you when he breaks the API of systemd that they hook into and the developers of your equivalent scramble to implement the binary protocol he thought up yesterday so that their alternative continues to work.

    I don’t want software on my system that is managed like that. It’s the same reason I prefer Firefox over anything Chromium based.

      • @AVincentInSpace
        link
        English
        107 months ago

        Borderline impossible if you aren’t using a distro designed with that in mind. Pretty much everything that isn’t a program you directly start (e.g. sound system, desktop environment, bluetooth daemon etc.) either only provide a systemd unit to start them (which you’ll have to manually translate into e.g. a shell script if you want it to work with your new init system) or is entirely reliant on systemd to function.

        Your choices of distro if you don’t want systemd are Debian, Void, Artix, and Gentoo, and afaik that’s about it.

        Replacing components of the systemd suite (e.g. using connman or networkmanager instead of systemd-networkd) isn’t actually that bad as long as your DE has support for them, but replacing systemd itself is something you are building your entire system around.

        • @pascal@lemm.ee
          link
          fedilink
          17 months ago

          Your choices of distro if you don’t want systemd are Debian, Void, Artix, and Gentoo, and afaik that’s about it.

          IIRC Debian was one of the first distros implementing systemd.

          • @AVincentInSpace
            link
            English
            17 months ago

            It still leaves sysvinit as an option. Debian doesn’t lock you into systemd. Heck, it doesn’t even lock you into Linux – you can use Debian on top of the FreeBSD kernel if you so desire

      • @MigratingtoLemmy@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        57 months ago

        Extremely. When things like your DE starts being dependent on systemd, you don’t want to replace it.

        I had posted about the monopoly that systemd has, and was down voted to oblivion.

    • @jbk@discuss.tchncs.de
      link
      fedilink
      17 months ago

      Lennart Poettering being completely unable to fathom why anyone would ever want to use any piece of software other than his

      What’s behind this? I’m sure it’s definitely not 100 % a single guy working on systemd, and tbh hating software because of the person who wrote it seems rather silly.

      And what about those API changes you mentioned? Genuinely curious, I thought it always at least mentions them in release notes during betas.

      • @HuntressHimbo@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        17 months ago

        You can look up Lennart Poettering yourself, but he was also involved in PulseAudio which if you learned Linux in the 00’s might give you pause, and has had some minor beef with Linus Torvalds before. His Wikipedia page has something like 5 paragraphs for controversies and 2 for his actual career.

        I think focusing on him is a mistake, but I also understand people who were still mad about PulseAudio latching on to him if they also had issues with Systemd. This article goes into some of it, but I can’t vouch fully for its accuracy. I will say that the dates of 2008 for PulseAudio’s release and 2012ish for when it became actually fairly functional lines up pretty roughly with my own memory, and systemd was released in 2010 and adopted by Arch and Debian in early 2012, so PulseAudio was barely fixed before the same developer started pushing Systemd, and succeeded in getting the normally very conservative Debian developers on board.

        https://linuxreviews.org/Lennart_Poettering#So_Much_Drama

        • @AVincentInSpace
          link
          English
          17 months ago

          that is such a great article. I can practically taste the edit warring.

      • @AVincentInSpace
        link
        English
        1
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        It appears I was mistaken – systemd does announce changes to internal interfaces on their mailing list although I can’t be bothered to find out how much warning they give – but I believe my point stands. Regardless of whether he gives adequate warning, he’s still very much a dick about it (“gentoo users, this is your wakeup call”) and he still seems to be doing the embrace-extend-extinguish thing. It used to be possible to run systemd-logind without systemd – it no longer is – and that mail I just linked is about making udev hard dependent as well.

        Of course Poettering does not do all the development himself, but he does lead the project and it is his hubris and inability to accept that one size does not fit all that is responsible for the project being as hostile to outside implementations as it is.

        Again, it’s not the systemd project making alternatives to widely used applications and daemons (or even bringing development of those applications under the systemd umbrella) that I mind. It’s Poettering’s “my way or the highway” attitude and apparent belief that if your system is not either 0% systemd or 100% systemd then you do not deserve to have a system that works.

        • @pascal@lemm.ee
          link
          fedilink
          27 months ago

          “gentoo users, this is your wakeup call”

          that was from 2014.

          As a gentoo user, he can go eat some dicks, my system today runs just fine.