Leading barrister warns that the kit – used to support gender-questioning children – is likely to be in breach of equality laws and could violate pupils’ rights

Archived version: https://archive.ph/jT7GK

  • @AVincentInSpace
    link
    English
    13 months ago

    Why do programs have default settings if they’re not the ideal settings for everyone?

    As I said in my previous comment, why shouldn’t the objective be to reach a point where transitioning is completely painless?

    • FfaerieOxide
      link
      fedilink
      13 months ago

      Why do programs have default settings if they’re not the ideal settings for everyone?

      I don’t think you can really compare screen resolution with the establishment of a disprivileged class that didn’t exist

      As I said in my previous comment, why shouldn’t the objective be to reach a point where transitioning is completely painless?

      Why should a person need to transition? Why do cis people need or deserve the privileged status there being a default they adhere to grants them?

      • @AVincentInSpace
        link
        English
        1
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        I don’t think you can really compare screen resolution with the establishment of a disprivileged class that didn’t exist

        I beg to differ. Screen readers aren’t enabled by default, and disabled people who need to access them often need the assistance of someone who can see the screen in order to enable them. Mainstream platforms such as Android are better about this (turning on the screen reader by holding both volume buttons down for 5 seconds), but even then people are required to know about the shortcut. I don’t think anyone would argue we should remedy this by turning the screen reader on by default, no? You could ask whether to turn on the screen reader during first time device setup, I suppose, but this analogy falls apart somewhat when applied to newborn babies.

        You have to call children something before they’re old enough to understand what gender is. Pose the question to them at age five and whatever they tell you is their gender from there on out, but there needs to be something before then. Five years is a long time for someone to not have a name.

        • FfaerieOxide
          link
          fedilink
          13 months ago

          Are you describing ableism as an argument against the existence of privileged classes??

          • @AVincentInSpace
            link
            English
            13 months ago

            No???

            Of course privileged classes exist. I just described one and described a way to lessen the impact of its existence, since eliminating it entirely is completely impossible.

            So too is the case with infants having names and genders.

            • FfaerieOxide
              link
              fedilink
              13 months ago

              lessen the impact of its existence

              You mean like not assigning people to classes we know can be incorrect they then would have to change?

              • @AVincentInSpace
                link
                English
                1
                edit-2
                3 months ago

                what. is. your. alternative.

                I swear you must not be reading my comments. How do you refer to a child for the first five years of their life if giving them a name, even a temporary one, is transphobic?

                • FfaerieOxide
                  link
                  fedilink
                  13 months ago

                  what. is. your. alternative.

                  Not shoving people into boxes we know aren’t accurate based on a 2 second glance at baby genitals.

                  Why is that even a thing you want to do?

                  • @AVincentInSpace
                    link
                    English
                    13 months ago

                    How do you refer to a child for the first five years of their life if giving them a name, even a temporary one, is transphobic?