Announcement Date: December 4, 2023
Standard:
- No changes
Pioneer:
-
Karn, the Great Creator is banned.
-
Geological Appraiser is banned.
-
Smuggler’s Copter is unbanned.
Modern:
- Fury is banned.
- Up the Beanstalk is banned.
Legacy:
- No changes
Vintage:
- No changes
Explorer:
- Karn, the Great Creator is banned.
- Geological Appraiser is banned.
Pauper:
- Monastery Swiftspear is banned.
Effective Date:
- Tabletop and Magic Online: December 4, 2023
- MTG Arena: December 5, 2023
About what I expected. Wouldn’t have minded Bowmasters, Grief or Ring biting the big one but that’s probably expecting too much
Yeah agreed on all accounts, would’ve loved to see those too.
I didn’t think Up the Beanstalk would get banned so soon but I think it’s a good hit to the 4c decks that are just a slog to play against.
Everything I’ve seen from Beans has just been absurd. There’s just so many high MV cards you can cast for 0-2 mana these days it’s a super easy value engine. Plus it cantrips before you even cast anything and I think that really pushes it over the edge
Can’t say I expected the Swifty ban. Glad to see Modern get a bit healthier, though.
Is it just me, or is “we’ll be changing the rate at which we update the B&R list from now on” a regular part of B&R announcements?
However, it is rare for a player to pay anywhere close to five mana to cast the cards they are using with Up the Beanstalk .
Yeah. I think Up the Beanstalk would be a pretty fair card if Magic were a game where you had to pay five mana to cast a five-mana spell.
Overall – a reasonable set of announcements which I think will probably have the expected outcomes.
Even if you’re not that interested in Pauper, Gavin Verhey’s separate article about the Swiftspear ban goes into a lot of detail about the thought process behind bannings & unbannings.
Removed by mod
