Reddit Was a Good Business
I joined Reddit in 2008. I remember it as a perpetual series of discoveries. Every time I logged in, I would learn something I never would have seen otherwise. New technology. New comedy. New ideology. New pornography. New ability to interpolate a unique string of characters related to current events and suddenly take control of a fresh memetic stream of independent media. New feelings, identities, behavior patterns, collective ethical architectures, and business opportunities. I was an isolated adolescent allergic to all the authority and social structure in my churchy suburban youth. Reddit was an electric neon string dangling from infinity and buzzing with the secular hum of freedom, sex, and reason. I grabbed on and didn’t let go for fifteen years.
We must remember it was always a business. It was an advertising marketplace operated for profit. It happened to operate at a particular scale which afforded small groups of key thinkers subjective judgements of the value of abstract concepts. For example, the value of community trust in an ad business.
I am guilty of describing recent events as “the death of Reddit.” While it’s cathartic to type after watching a community so formative to my identity sink into the swamp of astroturfed parasocial media hosting the U.S. Congress thinks is the same thing as “the Internet,” it’s wrong. Reddit didn’t die, it just outgrew its ideals. What died was that stupid moose. Furthermore, I’m glad it’s dead. It lied to me. It convinced me to forget something very important that Frank Herbert tried to tell me a long, long time ago.
The Spice Must Flow
Most people just want content. Sad but true. People living in specialized industrial/postindustrial societies have access to infinite sources of worry restricted only by the awareness of imminent death. The role of computers in society according to almost everyone alive is to help them hang on to their jobs or to temporarily distract them from their jobs. You can put the secret truth of the universe on tap and the vast majority of people simply won’t care unless it helps with one of those two things. It’s human nature; getting angry and vocal about it doesn’t change it. You are entitled to try.
It is because we know we will wither and die that we construct apparatuses to care for us in our impending weakness. For this reason, businesses of a certain size either grow or disappear.
Steve Huffman is taking a lot of shit right now, and that’s fair. That’s his job. My friends, do not confuse the face of the business for the inherent nature of the business. It is composed of mortals. Worse, it’s composed of software.
September Is a Function of Connectivity
If you’ve migrated to a federated Reddit substitute this week, you may have already encountered ActivityPub’s biggest limitation. Defederation is a massive pain in the ass. When a popular instance decides to take its toys and go home, everybody who was federated with them gets kicked in the metaphorical dick while the network figures out how to heal. On a technical level, the reason this is so expensive has to do with the inherent limitations of client-server architecture, but that’s a topic for another day. Right now, defederation is being used the way it was arguably intended: to protect communities who feel threatened by massive growth. Before you know it, the natural forces of conglomeration that killed our beloved Silly Moose will turn defederation into the same political token that’s represented by today’s private API. The gnashing of teeth will echo across the internet as pseudointellectuals like me bemoan the “death of the Fediverse.” They will be as wrong then as we are now, and we will be old.
In these fleeting moments preceding imminent death, we must use technology to love one another.
This situation has highlighted a conflict of ideals between the different groups that composed Reddit.
There’s a group who want the fediverse to succeed and are wholly committed to the tech - they forgo Reddit because they discuss the platform here.
There’s another that hates what Reddit represents and have been looking for the next Digg-to-Reddit style migration event. They are happy to be the catalyst for it, as they want everyone to migrate to a new platform entirely.
And then the remainder are people who want a stable homebase for content, with no particular interest in this situation. They stick to Reddit because it has the content in the format they can tolerate.
Right now, the first two groups have moved over here. We’re made up from the ~20-30%of older, grumpier, much less profitable Redditors. Make no mistake, Reddit is glad to see us go. The users who haven’t shifted yet genuinely don’t care about the issues that caused us to move.
Like you alluded to, if enough of the content creating users haven’t shifted (who probably represent 1% of total users) then this place is not attractive to the ~70% of users who haven’t moved. The first group don’t care about bringing Reddit over. The second group is basically demanding they move, but don’t understand why they won’t.
The solution is this:
Stop caring about beating Reddit.
Make non-drama related posts on your chosen Reddit alternative.
Grow communities that are welcoming.
Reddit isn’t in a direct rivalry with the fediverse. It’s in a war of attention with everything else. Discord is much more likely to be a threat to Reddit than Lemmy or Kbin. Some people will leave Reddit and not come here. Others who have never used Reddit will find their way here eventually. We shouldn’t look at this as Reddit’s death, but as the birth of a new platform that lives along side all the rest.