alt-text

Social Media Post:
Star Trek fans have held the national stereotype of being way too rabid about things for decades but they’re probably the nicest fan base in all of science fiction and the one least likely to have a large faction of them absolutely lose it over a torpedo being fired by a woman or dumb shit like that

Source (login walled)

  • Bappity
    link
    fedilink
    English
    11718 days ago

    anyone that tries to say star trek has “gone woke” or some stupid shit like that clearly isn’t a fan of it and just trying to rile up stuff. I mean come on… how can someone say that and have watched the shows LOL

    • @pleasejustdie@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      7818 days ago

      Yeah, its not like Star Trek suddenly went woke, its been woke. First ever TV kiss between mixed races was between Kirk and Uhura. Scandalous.

      • @rufus@discuss.tchncs.de
        link
        fedilink
        -15
        edit-2
        18 days ago

        And they’re not even that woke. Afaik they still ocasionally eat animals in the 24th century. (Unless they’re Vulcan.) Watch The Orville if you want some proper progressive shit 😆

        • @BarrelAgedBoredom@lemm.ee
          link
          fedilink
          3218 days ago

          They have food replicators. The only thing not vegan about replicated meat is that they’d probably use your poop as bulk material to synthesize stuff

              • @ameancow@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                9
                edit-2
                18 days ago

                poop meat.

                Knowing how chemicals and carbon compounds are recycled in Earth’s ecosystem and taking into account factory farming, I would wager the line between poop to serving of hot steak is much a much less connected line on a ship that turns matter into its constituent energy patterns.

                Meanwhile on Earth we routinely have meat recalls because of e-coli contamination. Which is poop. As well as what we use to fertilize our root vegetables. Everyone is eating poop to some degree, it just becomes a problem when enough of it is in one spot to become contamination.

                • The replicators are also used to “recycle”, converting matter into energy, to be used for future replication.

                  I doubt they were hauling poop through space rather than converting it to poop energy for their next earl grey.

            • @BarrelAgedBoredom@lemm.ee
              link
              fedilink
              618 days ago

              True! Forgot about that. I think voyager had a few episodes with hunted game of some sort. The Klingons in general too. Guess actually trek isn’t super big on veganism haha

          • @rufus@discuss.tchncs.de
            link
            fedilink
            8
            edit-2
            18 days ago

            Yeah they have. But don’t they go on to tell in several episodes of all of the shows, how someones mom makes/made the best X/Y out of real ingredients and how much better that tastes than replicated food? And they eat on some planets with other people or on vacation… ?! Or someone worked in a restaurant?

          • @lightnsfw@reddthat.com
            link
            fedilink
            718 days ago

            I don’t think the Star Trek replicator use raw materials to produce stuff. I’m pretty sure it’s just energy converted into matter.

        • @CileTheSane@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          1118 days ago

          Watch The Orville if you want some proper progressive shit 😆

          You mean like “agree to date me or else I’ll date the younger clone of you?”

          • @Taleya@aussie.zone
            link
            fedilink
            -318 days ago

            You didn’t actually watch that ep, didja? Several tells there lol

            (Honestly if you wanted fucking problematic Gordon was right there)

          • Norah - She/They
            link
            fedilink
            English
            617 days ago

            And of course it shall always be the first kiss between a black woman and a white man in space on tv.

            I cracked up a bit at this. That was a great write up, I didn’t know before about Desilu’s involvement in making that kiss happen and their earlier milestone, that’s quite cool.

          • @Crashumbc@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            517 days ago

            Specifically why I said black/white. and peck on the cheek isn’t consider a “kiss” by most people. (although it probably caused a stir). This was also right in the middle of the black civil rights movement which made it that much more risky.

            • Flying SquidM
              link
              fedilink
              1117 days ago

              Okay then, you’ll have to go with Sammy again and Nancy Sinatra:

              That would have been in 1967. Plato’s Stepchildren was a year later.

              On top of that, you have to further specify that this is only on American TV, because Gordon Heath kissed Rosemary Harris in a production of Othello on the BBC in 1955.

                • Flying SquidM
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -217 days ago

                  Do you think insulting a mod will go well for you? And congratulations for proving the above meme incorrect about Star Trek being the nicest fan base.

                  Showing you that a passionate kiss between a white woman and a black woman happened on British television over a decade before Star Trek is not being pedantic. You were just wrong.

    • @Tattorack@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      -8
      edit-2
      16 days ago

      Right now it’s the modern entitled version of woke. Not the philosophical exploratory woke.

      Modern Trek tells you off for thinking differently while old Trek set an example to aspire to.

      And that’s only in the few limited moments NuTrek a actually bothers spending time on making an opinion, as most of it is cheaply written shlock to squeeze as much as possible out of underpaid VFX artists.

      • @usernamefactory@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        216 days ago

        Releasing Let That Be Your Last Battlefield at the height of the civil rights movement wasn’t some hypothetical philosophizing. That was pointed condemnation. Same with The Outcast’s attack on conversion therapy, or In The Hands of the Prophets’ take on religious dogmatism.

        Star Trek has always been happy to condemn bad ideas. If you think it’s just started telling people off now then you haven’t been paying attention.

        • @Tattorack@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          -216 days ago

          It was 100% philosophy, and leading by example, exactly as I said. It spent the entire episode showing the hypocrisy of the two characters and showed the crew of The Enterprise to be better than their millenia old squabble.

          It wasn’t 30 seconds of emotional finger pointing in between cheap action sci-fi.

          I’ve been paying perfect attention to Star Trek. But it seems like loads of people have simply forgotten how Star Trek got their point across.

    • Flying SquidM
      link
      fedilink
      3817 days ago

      And yet it still happens. There are right-wing bigots who watch Star Trek for the pew pew space battles and ignore the rest, sad as that may be.

      • @RamblingPanda@lemmynsfw.com
        link
        fedilink
        2117 days ago

        They are not Trek fans, they are violence fans. They are not welcome.

        I love Star Trek for the vision, the tech, the people and of course to hate Wesley. This is my utopia.

        • Flying SquidM
          link
          fedilink
          1117 days ago

          The funny thing is, unlike with most sci-fi, Starfleet usually only starts shooting as a last resort. They don’t even notice that.

          • @Hugin@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            1217 days ago

            The number of times in trek where they could easily destroy the ship or entity that was causing the problem in the episode is huge in Trek. But they spend most of the episode trying to figure out how solve the problem with the minimum damage to both sides.

            • Flying SquidM
              link
              fedilink
              917 days ago

              Talking it out instead of shooting first and asking questions later is one of the things I admire most about Star Trek. It was sold as essentially a space Western, but unlike your standard Western, it says that violence is not the answer, talking and understanding each other is the answer.

              And really, the only Westerns I truly enjoy are the same way. My favorite is The Gunfighter with Gregory Peck. He’s an aging “fastest gun in the west” who just wants to be reconciled with his wife and child, retire and live a quiet life. But he keeps getting challenged. Spoiler for a movie made in 1950: There’s only one gun fired in the entire film, shot at the titular Gunfighter by a young hotshot. As Peck’s character lays dying, he lets the hotshot know that the curse of a life of violence has been passed on and he’s about to have as dismal a life as the man he killed.

              The same sort of moral lesson Star Trek teaches.

              But they want John Wayne coming in blazing, shooting at those inhuman savages (they don’t have to worry about being called racist if they hate Cardassians).

          • @chiliedogg@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            417 days ago

            I also love how they have different types of leaders.

            Kirk is the Captain you’d love to have as a boss. He gets stuff done, but also has fun with it. He’d inspire loyalty through Charisma.

            He’s the captain you want standing by your side in a bar fight.

            Picard is the perfectly-distantly, dignified leader. He’s a diplomat and archaeologist who loves exploring not only space, but culture and the nature of life. His love for his crew is shown through his desire to develop them into better officers.

            He was the captain who kept you from getting into a fight.

            Sisko is the most militaristic of the Captains. We first meet him in a battle, and he doesn’t back down from many fights. When Picard was annoyed by Q he complained. When Sisko met Q he punched him. But Sisko was a great tactician who also had to be a diplomat in charge of a station inhabited mostly by people outside his command structure.

            He was the captain who punch someone in the throat if he thought there would be a fight.

            Janeway was a scientist and diplomat. She could be hard as iron, but she was absolutely devoted to her people and would do anything for them. Her loyalty would cause her to occasionally cross the line, however. More than any of the captains, she wanted to develop her crew into leaders. They had limited options for advancement, but she tried to give them all opportunities to grow. She also didn’t see any sense in playing fair if she was in the right.

            She was the captain that would bring a gun to a knife fight.

            • @CrazyLikeGollum@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              English
              517 days ago

              The funny thing is that, contrary to how they act in their roles as Captain, Kirk was a studious nerd and a bit of teacher’s pet at the academy while Picard was a hard-partying drunk who not only participated in, but started bar fights.

              Kirk would do his best to defend you in a bar fight and then would punish you after the fact, according to Star Fleet rules.

              Picard would try to stop the bar fight from happening to begin with, would break it up if it escalated, but probably wouldn’t defend you specifically unless you had a good reason for being in the fight. He would only punish you if you were in the wrong and then it would probably be something more creative, more immediately punishing, and less impactful (career-wise), then Star Fleet’s regulations prescribe.

              • @AngryCommieKender@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                1
                edit-2
                16 days ago

                Picard got stabbed in the heart in one of those academy bar fights. Might have cooled his jets a bit.

                Also, “a bit of a teacher’s pet‽‽‽” Kirk was so much of a golden boy teacher’s pet, he cheated on the Kobiashi Maru test by hacking the holodeck, and forcing a “win condition,” and the instructors allowed it to stand.

        • OK I love to laugh at Wesley, don’t get me wrong, but why the hate? I am a dirty casual it’s true. But next Gen is the one I know best, he wasn’t that bad was he?

          • @aeronmelon@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            817 days ago

            Because Wesley Crusher was written to be seen as an annoying kid who got in the way. That was the social slant of the time. But you watch those episodes now and you realize, “Hey, he was actually very smart, just trying to help, and he even saved the ship a couple of times.” So all the “Shut up, Wesley!” moments became so stupid, even if he did deserved it sometimes, that the community decided to lean into it ironically as an in-joke.

      • @Ziglin@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        216 days ago

        Then perhaps the qualification to be a Trekkie should be watching the original series. We’ll loose the VFX loving pew pew people.

      • @Tattorack@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        116 days ago

        Ah… I see some of them must’ve made it to the writing room on NuTrek… Because it’s pretty much nothing more than a VFX showcase these days.

        I miss the time when an entire episode was essentially the crew figuring out a moral dillema, or just some really weird space bullshit.

  • Captain Aggravated
    link
    fedilink
    English
    6618 days ago

    I have a theory:

    Star Trek fans were some of the earlier cosplayers. Trekkies were wearing Starfleet uniforms and Vulcan ears to conventions decades before the word “cosplay” was a thing. My father has a book called the Starfleet Technical Manual published in the 70’s that is basically an official guide for fans to build screen accurate costumes and props from, including sewing patterns for the various tunics and wrist-length dresses and a page of color swatches, plus dimensional drawings of tricorders, phasers and communicators.

    And the public at large in the 1970s wasn’t ready for that yet.

      • Jojo, Lady of the West
        link
        fedilink
        417 days ago

        Yeah, I wouldn’t be surprised to learn the ancient Greeks were cosplaying their favorite characters from the Trojan war or something. But the word cosplay is only attested from like 1993 in English and 1983 or so in Japan

    • @Infynis@midwest.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      1817 days ago

      I have that book! It’s super cool. It’s themed as a document made by the military about information on the Federation that leaked into the past.

      There’s also diagrams of space stations and ships, and small things, like how to properly decorate sleeves and badges for rank and division.

      • Captain Aggravated
        link
        fedilink
        English
        617 days ago

        I read my dad’s copy cover to cover as a kid, it’s a great bit of fluff for fans combined with a useful prop reference. It’s also fun that it’s basically all hand drawn, even the text pages look l Iike a draftsman hand lettered them.

      • Flying SquidM
        link
        fedilink
        5
        edit-2
        17 days ago

        I used to have the original black cover version. Long lost, sadly. I have it as an ebook though. The one Star Trek book from my youth I had to buy once when I saw it used was this one, which used to be canon until TNG threw almost all of it away. But Rick Sternbach illustrated it and the ideas are pretty fun.

        https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Star_Trek_Spaceflight_Chronology

        I think my favorite part is when an Earth expedition to Alpha Centauri meets Zefram Cochrane (TOS says he is from Alpha Centauri and there’s a lot of headcanon to explain it) and learns to communicate to him through mathematics. At the beginning, Cochrane draws a circle with a symbol next to it, the Earth mathematician realizes that it means pi and they move on from there.

        Looks like someone scanned in every page if you’re interested: https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/spaceflight-chronology.php

        Edit:

        As much as I love First Contact, in terms of world building, I like that so much more.

      • @CptEnder@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        517 days ago

        Oh man those technical drawings are MY SHIT. I got all the Star Wars ones. I’ll definitely see if I can track this down

    • flicker
      link
      fedilink
      3618 days ago

      I threw up the horns. It was nuts as a middle school girl, when Voyager first started airing, and everyone was so angry about Janeway and when I’d ask why they would turn red and shake their head, or change the topic.

      • @Crashumbc@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        2718 days ago

        The good old days, when sexist, racist, homophobes at least kept their mouths shut… Now they’d give you a speech about how she should be in the galley :(

    • @grrgyle@slrpnk.net
      link
      fedilink
      12
      edit-2
      17 days ago

      It’s true. It’s not been a totally smooth ride. It’s taken work to educate fellow fans, and making the intolerant unwelcome.

      Like there was early “controversy” about Geordie getting to be on the bridge. Which seemed kind of logical, but if you scratched below the surface you’d see how selective that critique was. That it was just racism and ableism

    • @samus12345@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      317 days ago

      I remember a comment saying that Tuvok was so anal his skin is brown on Usenet in 1995. Some things never change.

      • @Numberone@startrek.website
        link
        fedilink
        1617 days ago

        Head cannon is that 1/3 of voyager is taken up by a massive shuttle manufactory. It’s never discussed but it must be there…Otherwise, none of this shit makes any sense.😬

        • @Lydia_K@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1417 days ago

          The lower decks should have done a joke about the three ensigns on Voyager who did nothing except build shuttles the entire seven years.

        • @Cagi@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          13
          edit-2
          7 days ago

          They could do it in the shuttle bay, they wouldn’t need much more space than a finished shuttle takes up. We know they have shipboard replimats for larger things, I figure replicating and building standard shuttle models on long voyages has standardized procedures and steps like Lego instructions. You only need to replicate one piece at a time saving on space. Gotta replace your shuttles somehow on those 5 years missions and the nearest Starbase is months away.

          • @Infynis@midwest.social
            link
            fedilink
            English
            717 days ago

            Yeah, if designing and building the Delta Flyer only took one episode, I think it’s pretty safe to assume that making more shuttles is easy and boring, and that’s why we don’t see it. Voyager was cutting edge when she was lost too

        • Flying SquidM
          link
          fedilink
          917 days ago

          Ex Astris Scientia calculated that Voyager lost 17 shuttles in the Delta Quadrant.

      • @Fades@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1418 days ago

        I was always sad they never explored that sort of thing in an episode, didn’t have to be as big as the Delta Flyer but still!

  • Semi-Hemi-Lemmygod
    link
    fedilink
    English
    3417 days ago

    The Discworld fandom is another one you can’t be in if you’re an asshole because you clearly didn’t understand the source material.

  • Flying SquidM
    link
    fedilink
    24
    edit-2
    18 days ago

    Also, sorry everyone, I was a Trekkie first and I will always come back to Star Trek, but the MST3K fan base is the nicest fan base. The only two bitter arguments I’ve ever seen the community devolve into was Joel vs. Mike (now very moot) and “I hate Crow’s new lady voice” for the most recent season. Other than that, everyone is super nice to a fault. The MST3K forums is the friendliest forum I have ever been on.

    • @Evil_Shrubbery@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      1218 days ago

      Say that again and I’ll tuvix the shit out of you!!

      (Then there will be two of you, but better, Im showing you mercy)

      • Flying SquidM
        link
        fedilink
        2818 days ago

        You probably shouldn’t do the ‘two of the same guy’ thing (known in the trade as a ‘Reverse Tuvix’) where Star Trek is concerned…

        Don’t you dare tell me Andy Dick doesn’t count.

    • @djsoren19@yiffit.net
      link
      fedilink
      1818 days ago

      Maybe the recent controversy from Warhammer 40k where Games Workshop retconned women space marines into existence? I dunno, did Star Wars do something to trigger the sexists since then, that controversy is a few weeks old now.

      • JJROKCZ
        link
        fedilink
        7
        edit-2
        18 days ago

        Female adeptes custodes not Space marines. Makes little difference in the large picture but it’s possible within the lore to have female custodians as they’re all humans picked at birth and genetically altered/enhanced individually to make the best soldier they could ever be. GW just didn’t mention females being in that order for 30 years apparently lol

        Space marines are all male though, have been explicitly stated as being all male repeatedly and even recently with lore backing of the some of the organ implants and genetic modification templates only work on males since they’re based off the primarchs who were all male as sons of the emperor of mankind.

        I’ll end with saying that GW has done great with inclusion in recent years, even explicitly telling Nazis to go find another hobby if they don’t like that GW is making warhammer and warhammer 40k for everyone, of all races, genders, and religions. They’ve always had racial representation and some manner of gender representation in the guard and eldar but now they’re expanding and I’m all for it. I have no issues with any of it so long as GW doesn’t just say ignore the last ~40 years of established lore and even recent lore issuances because we would like to sell more models.

    • Optional
      link
      fedilink
      1318 days ago

      I took it as a (mistaken) reference to the scene in The Last Jedi when Vice Admiral Holdo (Laura Dern) rams into a star destroyer in hyperspace, a maneuver which destroyed both ships and made people wonder why they didn’t just hyperspace into shit all the time instead of building warships and getting shot all the time.

      It happened in the same point in the movie when she refuses multiple times to say that she has any plan whatsoever, leading to a lot of pointless fighting and was thought to have been some sort of commentary on “believing women” but very poorly executed.

      Disney spent billions to destroy the Star Wars canon, but hopefully Trek can escape such a grisly fate.

      • Kushan
        link
        fedilink
        English
        617 days ago

        In fairness, that scene with the destroyers was fucking awesome. Fuck the canon, it looked cool as fuck.

    • @Crashumbc@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      718 days ago

      Because the first series didn’t age well :( although I loved it at 10… And the second was (controversial opinion incoming) too much of a soap opera for me.

      • VindictiveJudge
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1218 days ago

        The writers and showrunners blatantly not having a clue where the plot was going was a bigger problem for me than the soapiness.

        • It’s weird how the show just vanished. Even without all the sequels and prequels Star Wars would still have been endlessly referenced for decades after the 2nd movie. BSG is the cultural equivalent of a night of heavy drinking.

          I remember binge watching it. I remember talking to people about it but nothing this past decade

          • VindictiveJudge
            link
            fedilink
            English
            417 days ago

            Even without all the sequels and prequels Star Wars would still have been endlessly referenced for decades after the 2nd movie.

            Not necessarily. Being able to stick the landing is hugely important for a series’ legacy. Game of Thrones disappeared from conversation after its disastrous final season, but would probably be fondly remembered if it had been suddenly cancelled after season five. If ROTJ had been a similar dumpster fire, Star Wars might have gone the same way.

          • Captain Aggravated
            link
            fedilink
            English
            216 days ago

            Notice how basically no one ever mentions Lost or Game of Thrones anymore?

            These shows were HUGE during their time. “This is AMAZING. Television has never been like this before. You can’t be an adult in society if you haven’t seen last night’s episode because if you say you don’t watch this show the conversation will immediately end.” soon “What the fuck was that ending? The last season turned to shit! Never mention this shit to me again.”

            It’s like VindictiveJudge says, these shows are designed to feel like they’re going places but never actually get there. The writers of Lost put shit in that they thought looked intriguing but they hadn’t thought of any way to resolve it into something. “What do the numbers mean?!” Nothing! Absolutely nothing!

            Those shows are built like big epic stories, they’re not Star Trek type adventure of the week that returns to the status quo, and yet they’re not designed to resolve. Of course you’re going to leave unsatisfied.

      • @Maggoty@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        117 days ago

        The second seemed like an asset rip to me. It wasn’t bad per se, it just wasn’t Battlestar Galactica.

    • Captain Aggravated
      link
      fedilink
      English
      016 days ago

      The original old show? It’s meh okay 70’s sci-fi TV. Not into the kid and his robot dog or whatever.

      The 2000s remake? It’s basically what cured my television habit. I was never really into the “gritty realistic” heartburn drama shit anyway, so I gave up on the show itself pretty early, then spent the rest of my time as an SG-1 fan having Katee Sackhoff scream in anguish at me during every single commercial break for years on end. Then every TV show made from then on had to be a dark and brooding show about terrible people being terrible to each other and then I stopped watching TV.

  • @Evil_Shrubbery@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    15
    edit-2
    17 days ago

    Completely agree.

    If I would ever be in desperate need of help it would instantly comfort me to see a trekkie or a metalhead. The average wholesomeness is ridiculously high.

  • Seraph
    link
    fedilink
    1418 days ago

    So you’re saying Star Trek needs its own version of Jar Jar?

    • VindictiveJudge
      link
      fedilink
      English
      818 days ago

      It still bugs me that they make a big deal about how few resources they have and then fire so many torpedoes and lose so many shuttles. I would have loved to have seen them pick up some locally sourced equipment.

      • smoothbrain coldtakes
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1418 days ago

        Honestly, my thought was always just that they could replicate equipment and components as needed but it was a power intensive process.

        There is a whole episode of Voyager where they land the ship to do repairs on it, and I just figure that happens more than we’re shown.

        I agree though, I would have preferred Voyager to have all crazy Borg shit forever. Would have been sick to have all this jury-rigged bullshit, almost like how DS9 is totally fucked.

        • VindictiveJudge
          link
          fedilink
          English
          318 days ago

          They also designed and built a custom shuttle, but iirc it was an open question as to whether or not the ship’s larger replicators could handle it, which implies they left with all the shuttles they lost and the Delta Flyer was the first they made.